Recent fighting game reviews: Street Fighter IV, Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, Punch-Out!!

There has definitely been a resurgence in one-on-one fighting games over the last 2 or 3 years.  I recently dug into a few that represent long-running series that I’ve enjoyed.  An interesting trend among the games I review in this post is that the publishers of these series decided to farm the games to outside developers.  I guess Japanese publishers just hate to develop their own games.

Super Street Fighter IV
2010 (this is a revised version of a game originally released in 2008)
developer: Dimps/Capcom
publisher: Capcom
format: Xbox 360 (also available on PlayStation 3, Windows and – in a miniature-sized version – iPod)

Ramble: In 2008, Capcom revived its famous Street Fighter IV with the arcade release, Street Fighter IV, which was ported to PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 the following year.  In typical Capcom fashion, the game has been upgraded and re-released with Super in the title.  Since I never played the original, I can’t offer much in the way of a comparison but from what I’ve heard it’s what one would expect: new characters, new combos, new fight locations.

Anyway, as for the game itself, if you like Street Fighter II and Street Fighter Alpha, you will like this game.  That may seem like a no-brainer but it hasn’t always been the case with previous Street Fighter games.  For example, Street Fighter III, while highly rated by critics and fighting game afficionados for its great animations, messed with the formula enough to be less commercial.  The Street Fighter EX series was never universally accepted by SFII buffs, either.

In many ways, SFIV feels like a remake of SFII.  For example, the original SFIV cast largely consisted of the 12 characters from the original version of SFII.  All of the Super SFII characters have made it over to Super SFIV, as well.  Super SFIV also includes several characters from SF Alpha but only a handful from SFIII and just a few original characters.  Another element that makes SFIV feel remake-y is that the characters seem to be frozen in time, presented basically as they were in either SFII or SF Alpha.  This is definitely a problem for me.  In SF Alpha, the character Cody is supposed to have recently escaped from jail and is thus portrayed as wearing a prison outfit.  In SF IV, which takes place story-wise after SF Alpha, SF, and SFII, Cody is still wearing a prison outfit.  Dang, dude, find some new clothes.  Sakura is still wearing her pervy schoolgirl outfit.  Rose is wearing the exact same dress from SF Alpha.  Admittedly, you can buy new outfits for the characters but to buy every outfit would cost you $16.  EL OH EL!

The best: The game plays very well.  Many of the characters have picked up some new moves to change things up.  The art style is also great but doesn’t come across as stylized as it seemed to be portrayed in gaming publications.  It may seem remake-y but still has its own style and feels fresh in ways that count.

The worst: The fighting locations are basically random.  In SFII, each character had their own cool fight location that reflected his or her personality or culture to some degree.  E. Honda fought in a Japanese bath house, Dalsihm fought in an elephant stable, Guild fought on a military base, etc.  In SFIV, you and your opponent are just whisked off to some random location and you fight.  Another complaint is that the final boss is totally generic and boring, a problem that SFIII had, as well.  SF‘s Sagat and SFII‘s and SF Alpha‘s M. Bison were cool and memorable, but this new guy will never be remembered.

Grade: B+


Tatsunoko vs. Capcom: Ultimate All-Stars
2008 (didn’t make it to the US until 2009)
developer: Eighting
publisher: Capcom
system: Wii

Ramble: Tatsunoko vs. Capcom is essentially a descendant of the Marvel vs. Capcom series, featuring the trademark simplified control scheme and fast and wild action that series is known for.  This game received pretty good reviews but I just don’t see it.  The combos seem to be the same across the roster there is at least one combo that’s mega simple and spammable.

The Capcom characters chosen for the game are pretty terrible, too.  Only a few are from fighting games, which could be okay, but two slots are wasted on Mega Man Volnutt from the Mega Man Legends series and his pal, Roll.  Meanwhile, dudes like Arthur of Ghosts ‘n Goblins fame have still not appeared as a playable character in one of these vs. games.  At least Viewtiful Joe made the cut, a selection that actually makes sense due to his brawling nature.

Unfortunately, the fighting falls flat for the most part and characters seem relatively unbalanced.  I beat the game without losing a single match on my first playthrough by using Ryu and Alex (of SFIII fame).  Playing with midgets like Viewtiful Joe and Roll offers a more difficult challenge due to imbalances.

The best: The visuals are pretty good.

The worst: The gameplay falls quite flat compared to the Marvel vs. Capcom series and just makes me want to play those games instead.  Almost as weak as the gameplay is a topic I haven’t addressed yet at all – the Tatsunoko cast.  I’m sure some people will think my reaction to the Tatsunoko roster is due to my lack of familiarity with the properties but I assure this is not the case.  For an American equivalent of the lame Tatsunoko cast, I would invite one to look at Hanna-Barbera.  Most of the Tatsunoko fighters are boring super hero types in the same mold as Space Ghost.

Grade: C+


developer: Next Level
publisher: Nintendo
system: Wii

Ramble: After fifteen years of neglect, Nintendo finally dumped the Punch-Out!! property on developer Next Level to bring us a new game.  Sorta.  Much like SFIV, the Wii Punch-Out!! feels like a remake of an earlier game, specifically Mike Tyson’s Punch-Out!!, released for the NES.  Just like the NES game, the new entry follows a bout format of 3 rounds consisting of 3 minutes each, unlike the SNES game which features bouts of just 1 round.  In fact, advancements presented in the SNES entry are largely ignored, including the cool characters that made their debut in that awesome effort.

In the new Punch-Out!!, earning super punches becomes extremely important, as it’s the key to defeating some enemies.  Speaking of enemies, there are only 13 in the standard game.  If you have spent a lot of time playing the previous Punch-Out!! games you’ll get through the first six or so opponents without much trouble but matters do become more challenging after that.  Most of your opponents have picked up new tricks, changed their moves, or completely changed their timing since the last time you saw them.

After beating the main game, the 13 fighters challenge you for your title and there are pretty big changes the 2nd time around.  This is where I currently am in the game, and the difficulty is definitely amped up, considering I haven’t even beaten Glass Joe – who is now protected by headgear (LOL) and has a crazy punch timing.  This challenge mode effectively doubles the length of the game in a manner that is much more enjoyable than simply making the fighters harder.

If you like the NES version, I have little doubt you’ll like, and maybe even prefer, the Wii remake.

The best: The characterizations are great and the various boxers speak in their native languages.  The fighting is solid and does the series justice.  The challenge mode is a simple but ingenious addition.

The worst: There should really be more characters and more than just a single new fighter.  Ignoring the contributions of the as-yet untopped Super Punch-Out!! (SNES) isn’t too cool, either.

Grade: B+

5 responses to “Recent fighting game reviews: Street Fighter IV, Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, Punch-Out!!

  1. what contributions from super punch out did you want to see in this one?

  2. I like the fight structure in Super PO – each bout is just one round, 3 minutes. The fighting is much smoother in that than in NES PO, as well. Wii PO also ignores the new characters from Super PO for no good reason.

    Super PO is all-around approximately FIVE TIMES better than NES PO.

  3. it would have been cool to have more characters. it did include bear hugger and aran ryan, though.

    i do appreciate a multiplication scale, though.

  4. Those dudes have been around since the original arcade Punch-Outs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s